1. For this letter and Robert Richardson's reply, see Christian Baptist, 14th ed., pp. 599ff.
      2. Matt. 10:34-37, Campbell's version, Living Oracles, 1826.
      3. Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers.

      1. Trinity Cathedral records.
      2. Agnes Lynch Starrett, Through One Hundred and Fifty Years, p. 164. University of Pittsburgh Press.
      3. Robert Richardson, Memoirs of Alexander Campbell, Vol. I, p. 463.
      4. Idem, p. 464.
      5. Idem, p. 506.
      6. Idem, p. 509.
      7. Dwight E. Stevenson, Walter Scott: Voice of the Golden Oracle, pp. 30-32. Christian Board of Publication, St. Louis, 1946.
      8. Idem, pp. 36f.
      9. Richardson, op. cit. Vol. I, p. 508.

      1. Stevenson, Walter Scott: Voice of the Golden Oracle, p. 41.
      2. Starrett, Through One Hundred and Fifty Years, pp. 75f.
      3. Leland D. Baldwin, Pittsburgh, the Story of a City, pp. 157f.
      4. Idem, pp. 250f.
      5. Theodore Diller, Pioneer Medicine in Western Pennsylvania, pp. 42f. Paul B. Hoeber, Inc., Medical Book Department of Harper & Brothers, New York and London.
      6. Official records of the Medical School, confirmed by a letter from the assistant dean, April 7, 1947.
      7. Christian Baptist, 14th ed., p. 601.
      8. Richardson, Memoirs of Alexander Campbell, Vol. II, p. 297.
      9. Stevenson, op. cit. pp. 71-80.
      10. Winfred E. Garrison, Religion Follows the Frontier, p. 200. Harper & Brothers, New York and London, 1931.
      11. Richardson, op. cit. Vol. II, p. 298.

      1. Richardson, Memoirs of Alexander Campbell, Vol. II, p. 299.
      2. M. C. Tiers, The Christian Portrait Gallery, p. 158.
      3. W. C. Morro, Brother McGarvey, p. 158. Bethany Press, St. Louis, 1940.
      4. Millennial Harbinger, 1830, p. 1.
      5. Richardson, op. cit., pp. 326f.
      6. Millennial Harbinger, 1830, p. 206.
      7. Evangelist, 1832, p. 203.
      8. Idem, p. 205. [237]
      9. Idem, pp. 211f.
      10. Wellsburg church records, written in Robert Richardson's hand.

      1. Evangelist, 1834, pp. 34f., 49f., 110f.
      2. Idem, pp. 25-29, 98-109.
      3. Richardson, Memoirs of Alexander Campbell, Vol. II, pp. 394f. See also, Evangelist, 1834, pp. 97f., 121f.
      4. Millennial Harbinger, 1834, pp. 385-444.
      5. Carthage church records.
      6. Date of birth on tombstone, Campbell Cemetery, Bethany.
      7. Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers; a letter by Alexander Campbell to Robert Richardson, Dec. 29, 1835.
      8. Millennial Harbinger, 1835, p. 612, dated Nov. 3, 1835.
      9. Idem, pp. 617f.
      10. Idem, 1836, p. 184.
      11. W. T. Moore, Comprehensive History of the Disciples of Christ, p. 281. Fleming H. Revell Co., New York, London, Edinburgh, 1909.

      1. Millennial Harbinger, 1836, p. 239.
      2. Idem, 1835, p. 618.
      3. Idem, 1836, p. 233.
      4. Idem, pp. 393f.
      5. Idem, pp. 333, 335.
      6. Idem, 1838, p. 199.
      7. Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers.
      8. Millennial Harbinger, 1836, pp. 345-49.
      9. B. L. Smith, Alexander Campbell, p. 325. Bethany Press, St. Louis, 1930.
      10. Moore, Comprehensive History of the Disciples of Christ, p. 281.
      11. Millennial Harbinger, 1836, p. 480.
      12. Idem, 1837, pp. 451-60.
      13. Idem, pp. 500-506.
      14. Idem, 1838, p. 479.

      1. Millennial Harbinger, 1839, p. 289.
      2. W. R. Warren, The Life and Labors of Archibald McLean, pp. 60f. United Christian Missionary Society, Indianapolis, 1923.
      3. Sue Sublette, in the Christian Standard, Nov. 14, 1896.
      4. Millennial Harbinger, 1839, pp. 446-51.

      1. Millennial Harbinger, 1839, p. 448. Cf. W. K. Woolery, Bethany Years, pp. 28f.
      2. Millennial Harbinger, 1839, p. 450.
      3. Woolery, op. cit., p. 31.
      4. Charter of Bethany College, in Millennial Harbinger, 1840, pp. 176-79.
      5. Minutes of the Board of Trustees of Bethany College.
      6. Millennial Harbinger, 1840, pp. 509f.
      7. Idem, p. 179.
      8. Idem, 1841, p. 269. [238]
      9. Woolery, op. cit., pp. 35f.
      10. Idem, p. 54.
      11. Idem, p. 48.
      12. Millennial Harbinger, 1842, p. 36.
      13. Minutes of the Board of Trustees of Bethany College.
      14. Millennial Harbinger, 1842, pp. 29-33.
      15. Woolery, op. cit., p. 68.
      16. Morro, Brother McGarvey, p. 56.

      1. Minutes of the Board of Trustees of Bethany College.
      2. Millennial Harbinger, 1842, p. 319.
      3. Minutes of the Board of Trustees of Bethany College.
      4. Millennial Harbinger, 1842, p. 143.
      5. Idem, p. 383.
      6. Idem, 1843, p. 473.
      7. Bethany College Catalogue, July, 1843.
      8. Millennial Harbinger, 1843, pp. 281-83.
      9. Idem, p. 373.
      10. Idem, p. 277.
      11. This whole section on the power of the president and the rights of the professors is based on the minutes of the Board of Trustees of Bethany College.
      12. Millennial Harbinger, 1841, pp. 491f.
      13. Idem, pp. 241-45.
      14. Idem, 1843, pp. 124-28.
      15. Smith, Alexander Campbell, p. 328.
      16. Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers; a letter from Bethphage, July 16, 1857.
      17. Millennial Harbinger, 1843, p. 567.
      18. Idem, 1854, pp. 181-200.

      1. Millennial Harbinger, 1848, p. 530.
      2. A. S. Hayden, Early History of the Disciples in the Western Reserve, Ohio, pp. 260-66. Chase & Hall, Cincinnati, 1875.
      3. Millennial Harbinger; 1847, p. 716.
      4. Idem, p. 134.
      5. Idem, 1849, pp. 661-64.

      1. Frederick D. Power, Life of William Kimbrough Pendleton, p. 139. Christian Publishing Co., St. Louis, 1902.
      2. Minutes of the Board of Trustees of Bethany College, July 3, 1851.
      3. Woolery, Bethany Years, pp. 45f.
      4. Millennial Harbinger, 1854, pp. 117f.
      5. Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, June 21, 1855.
      6. Idem, June 27, 1855.
      7. Mary Richardson Chapline, "Father's Likes and Dislikes."
      8. Millennial Harbinger, 1854, p. 653. [239]
      9. Idem, 1855, p. 293.
      10. Idem, pp. 517-20.
      11. Idem, 1853, p. 297.
      12. Idem, p. 117.
      13. Idem, 1854, p. 232.
      14. Robert Richardson, Principles and Objects of the Religious Reformation, pp. 6f.
      15. Idem, p. 7.
      16. Idem, p. 13.
      17. Idem, p. 26.
      18. Idem, pp. 26f.
      19. Idem, p. 29.
      20. Idem, p. 31.
      21. Idem, p. 37.
      22. Idem, p. 44.
      23. J. S. Lamar, Memoirs of Isaac Errett, Vol. I, p. 147. Standard Publishing Co., Cincinnati, 1893.

      1. Millennial Harbinger, 1856, p. 151.
      2. Idem, p. 174.
      3. W. K. Pendleton's letters.
      4. Millennial Harbinger, 1856, p. 154.
      5. Idem, 1857, pp. 82-85.
      6. Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers.
      7. Robert Richardson, Communings in the Sanctuary, pp. 32f. Transylvania Press (year of publication unknown).
      8. Morro, Brother McGarvey, p. 60.
      9. Richardson, op. cit., p. 18.
      10. Idem, pp. 68f.
      11. Idem, pp. 143f.
      12. Idem, pp. 112f.
      13. Idem, p. 73.
      14. Idem, pp. 114f.
      15. Idem, p. 156.
      16. Idem, p. 147.
      17. Idem, pp. 71f.

      1. Millennial Harbinger, 1857, p. 407.
      2. Woolery, Bethany Years, p. 60.
      3. Millennial Harbinger, 1857, p. 134.
      4. The details of the controversies traced in this chapter are to be found in the following pages of the Millennial Harbinger: 1857, pp. 134-37, 191-97, 255-59, 265-76, 328-36, 395-406, 433-48, 481-85, 491-95, 546-51, 559-67, 573-80, 692-703; 1858, pp. 86, 199-205, 289f., 353; 1859, pp. 39f., 54; also in the Evangelist for 1858, pp. 67f.; also in the private correspondence of Robert Richardson with Philip S. Fall for July 30, 1857, Aug. 24, 1857, Sept. 23, 1857, Dec. 15, 1858, Dec. 19, 1859; with Isaac Errett for July 16, 1857; and with Reuben L. Coleman for July 16, 1857; also in Alexander Campbell's letter to P. S. Fall for Jan. 4, 1860; and the minutes of the Board of Trustees of Bethany College. The letters, except for those to P. S. Fall, are in Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers.
      5. Woolery, op. cit., p. 89.
      6. Minutes of the Board of Trustees of Bethany College. [240]

      1. Richardson to P. S. Fall, Dec. 15, 1858.
      2. Ibid.
      3. This and succeeding items of information about Bacon College and Kentucky University, except where noted, are from Alonzo W. Fortune, The Disciples in Kentucky, pp. 191-94.
      4. Minutes of the Board of Curators, Kentucky University.
      5. Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers.
      6. Minutes of the Board of Curators, Kentucky University.
      7. Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers.
      8. Philip S. Fall correspondence.
      9. Millennial Harbinger, 1859, pp. 39f., 54.
      10. Minutes of the Board of Trustees of Bethany College.
      11. Woolery, Bethany Years, pp. 90-92.
      12. Minutes of the Board of Trustees of Bethany College.
      13. Biographical and Historical Catalogue of Washington and Jefferson College, p. 563. George H. Buchanan Co., Philadelphia, 1902.
      14. Millennial Harbinger, 1859, p. 532.
      15. Idem, p. 597.

      1. Fortune, The Disciples in Kentucky, p. 194.
      2. Catalogue of Kentucky University, 1861, p. 20.
      3. Fortune, op. cit., p. 194.
      4. Millennial Harbinger, 1860, p. 474.
      5. Alexander Campbell to P. S. Fall, Jan. 4, 1860.
      6. Richardson to P. S. Fall, Dec. 19, 1859.
      7. Millennial Harbinger, 1862, pp. 41f.
      8. Idem, 1861, pp. 712f.
      9. Idem, 1862, pp. 97f. (footnote).
      10. Idem, 1861, p. 711.
      11. Idem, pp. 712f.
      12. Robert Milligan letter to Richardson, Aug. 11, 1862, in Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers.
      13. Fortune, op. cit., pp. 194f.
      14. Millennial Harbinger, 1867, pp. 277-85.
      15. P. S. Fall to Richardson, Dec. 13, 1862.
      16. Oral tradition, through Mrs. W. W. Pilchard, Bethany.
      17. Fortune, op. cit., pp. 194f.

      1. Catalogue of the Officers, Alumni and Students of Bethany College for the 20th, 21st, 22nd, 23rd, and 24th Sessions, Ending July 4, 1865, p. 14.
      2. Millennial Harbinger, 1865, pp. 429f.
      3. Richardson, Memoirs of Alexander Campbell, Vol. II, p. 674.
      4. Idem, pp. 674f.
      5. Millennial Harbinger, 1866, p. 141.
      6. Richardson, op. cit., p. 679. [241]
      7. Millennial Harbinger, 1866, pp. 141f.
      8. Richardson, op. cit., Vol. I, p. 2.
      9. Idem, p. 3.
      10. Millennial Harbinger, 1866, 185.
      11. Richards on, op. cit., p. 3.
      12. Robert Richardson notebook.
      13. Mrs. G. L. Wharton, "Father's Last Days."
      14. Richardson, op. cit., p. 5.
      15. Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers.
      16. Isaac Errett to Richardson, June 22, 1868, in Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers.
      17. Millennial Harbinger, 1869, p. 718.

      1. Millennial Harbinger, 1869, p. 405.
      2. Minutes of the Board of Trustees of Bethany College.
      3. Woolery, Bethany Years, p. 117.
      4. Bethany oral tradition.
      5. Goodnight's transcript of Richardson's private papers.
      6. Lamar, Memoirs of Isaac Errett, Vol. II, p. 44.
      7. Wharton, "Father's Last Days." [242]

[HTB 237-242]