THE MAN OR THE PLAN?
K. C. MOSER AND THE THEOLOGY OF GRACE
AMONG MID-TWENTIETH CENTURY
CHURCHES OF CHRIST*  

Dr. John Mark Hicks
Harding University Graduate School of Religion


OUTLINE

   I. Introduction.
      A. Reuel Lemmons' 1962 Firm Foundation Editorial.
      B. Kenney Carl Moser (1893-1976).
      C. Purpose of Paper.

  II. Moser's Theology of Grace.
      A. Early Writing in the Firm Foundation (1920-32).
      B. The Way of Salvation (1932).
          1. Varied Reaction to the Book.
              a. Foy E. Wallace, Jr.
              b. G. C. Brewer.
          2. Exposition of the Book.
      C. "Are We Preaching the Gospel of Christ?" (1937).
          1. Moser and the Gospel Advocate.
          2. Exposition of the Pamphlet.
      D. "Christ Versus a Plan" (1952).
          1. Legalism on the Right and Left.
          2. Exposition of the Pamphlet.
      E. The Gist of Romans (1957).
          1. Setting and Purpose of the Book.
          2. G. C. Brewer's Fear.

III. Historical Interpretation.
      A. The Context.
           1. Roy Key's Article in 1946 Advocate.
           2. Commendation by G. C. Brewer.
      B. Nashville Bible School and the Theology of Grace.
           1. David Lipscomb.
           2. James A. Harding.
           3. J. N. Armstrong.
           4. Robert H. Boll.
           5. R. C. Bell.
           6. G. C. Brewer.
      C. Opposition to Moser.
           1. Current Opposition.
           2. G. H. P. Showalter.
           3. Foy E. Wallace, Jr.
           4. The West-East Shift.

IV. Theological Analysis.
      A. Emphasis on the Man.
           1. Legalistic Preaching.
           2. Legalistic Justification.
           3. Legalistic Sanctification.
      B. Emphasis on the Plan.
           1. Calvinistic "Grace Only."
           2. Calvinistic "Faith Only."
           3. Antinomianism.
      C. Two Theological Grammars.
           1. Similarities: Common Ground.
           2. Essential Difference.
               a. "Righteousness of God."
               b. The Righteousness We Do.
               c. The Righteousness We Maintain.
               d. Problem of Assurance.
           3. The Man or the Plan?

 V. Conclusion.
      A. Moser and the East-West Difference.
      B. Moser and the East-West Shift.


*  A paper presented for the 18th Annual W. B. West Lectures for the Advancement of Christian     Scholarship on October 5, 1993. [back]


Contents
Next